On the Debian Maintainers GR
Hmh… It’s hard to get to a decision on this aspect, although I’m mostly sure I’ll vote for a “yes”. I have read most posts on this subject on debian-vote and on the planet, and I’m still not too much at ease… Anyway, one of the most relevants so far is Joerg’s - And not because he is so involved with the NM process, but because he drives me to what I think is a very important point few people have addressed:
For long, we have been saying that you don’t have to be a programmer to help Debian - But so far, we have been unable to deliver
except for this funny French guy. And although the current proposal still focuses on getting a step closer to DDness, and for many people this seems like geared at reducing the frustration when going over the NM process, my impression is that this will help us implement something similar for other areas.
Some people have complained about implementing decisions per policy instead of doing so gradually. Thing is, I feel, this kind of proposals have been reiterated over the years - and they have always dropped into the silence because some actions need to be taken by the people who are less willing to. Maybe the only way to break the inertia is to take a step by a GR vote. Maybe parts of it will have to be undone or re-done differently if we end up with the wrong results - but we will have broken the status-quo. Maybe, who knows, this will serve as an experiment - and after another long series of long flame threads we will end up in 2010 in the same position are we currently at - but it won’t be because of inaction.